72

I know the modulus (%) operator calculates the remainder of a division. How can I identify a situation where I would need to use the modulus operator?

I know I can use the modulus operator to see whether a number is even or odd and prime or composite, but that's about it. I don't often think in terms of remainders. I'm sure the modulus operator is useful, and I would like to learn to take advantage of it.

I just have problems identifying where the modulus operator is applicable. In various programming situations, it is difficult for me to see a problem and realize "Hey! The remainder of division would work here!".

1
  • Essentially, it is used for time, dates and sequence repetition Commented Jul 19, 2016 at 20:49

19 Answers 19

28

Imagine that you have an elapsed time in seconds and you want to convert this to hours, minutes, and seconds:

h = s / 3600; m = (s / 60) % 60; s = s % 60; 
Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

Comments

21
0 % 3 = 0; 1 % 3 = 1; 2 % 3 = 2; 3 % 3 = 0; 

Did you see what it did? At the last step it went back to zero. This could be used in situations like:

  1. To check if N is divisible by M (for example, odd or even) or N is a multiple of M.

  2. To put a cap of a particular value. In this case 3.

  3. To get the last M digits of a number -> N % (10^M).

2 Comments

Can you explain situation number 3? To get the last M digits of a number -> N % (10^M).
For example, in a Advent calendar chocolate that is to divide by 3 people. Anna gets to open the calendar door/window at the first day (1) and eat the chocolate, Ben in day 2 and Carl in day 3, then again Anna, and so on. Make a 'day % 3' and when result is 1: Anna, 2: Ben, 0:Carl. Everyone gets their chocolate without big computation.
18

I use it for progress bars and the like that mark progress through a big loop. The progress is only reported every nth time through the loop, or when count%n == 0.

2 Comments

You too, then? It really makes a big speed difference.
It does indeed. For an even faster version, I like to use bit logic: count & 0xff == 0 (you can use 0xf or 0xff or 0xfff or such: the point is having a number that in binary is a solid string of 1s)
12

I've used it when restricting a number to a certain multiple:

temp = x - (x % 10); //Restrict x to being a multiple of 10 

1 Comment

Can you give a practical usage of this?
11
  • Wrapping values (like a clock).
  • Provide finite fields to symmetric key algorithms.
  • Bitwise operations.

And so on.

Comments

7

One use case I saw recently was when you need to reverse a number. So that 123456 becomes 654321 for example.

int number = 123456; int reversed = 0; while ( number > 0 ) { # The modulus here retrieves the last digit in the specified number # In the first iteration of this loop it's going to be 6, then 5, ... # We are multiplying reversed by 10 first, to move the number one decimal place to the left. # For example, if we are at the second iteration of this loop, # reversed gonna be 6, so 6 * 10 + 12345 % 10 => 60 + 5 reversed = reversed * 10 + number % 10; number = number / 10; } 

Comments

6

Example. You have message of X bytes, but in your protocol maximum size is Y and Y < X. Try to write small app that splits message into packets and you will run into mod :)

Comments

5

There are many instances where it is useful.

If you need to restrict a number to be within a certain range you can use mod. For example, to generate a random number between 0 and 99 you might say:

num = MyRandFunction() % 100; 

3 Comments

-1. This will generate non-uniform results unless 100 is a divisor of the range of MyRandFunction(). (Imagine you want a random numbers in 0 .. RAND_MAX*2/3.)
@KennyTM: +1. What would probably be better is to be able to pass the 100 into MyRandFunction() which would take care of it properly. Plus that provides better encapsulation, and much looser coupling.
Up-voted for another common use case. (question isn't about generating crypto sound psrn's)
5

Any time you have division and want to express the remainder other than in decimal, the mod operator is appropriate. Things that come to mind are generally when you want to do something human-readable with the remainder. Listing how many items you could put into buckets and saying "5 left over" is good.

Also, if you're ever in a situation where you may be accruing rounding errors, modulo division is good. If you're dividing by 3 quite often, for example, you don't want to be passing .33333 around as the remainder. Passing the remainder and divisor (i.e. the fraction) is appropriate.

Comments

5

As @jweyrich says, wrapping values. I've found mod very handy when I have a finite list and I want to iterate over it in a loop - like a fixed list of colors for some UI elements, like chart series, where I want all the series to be different, to the extent possible, but when I've run out of colors, just to start over at the beginning. This can also be used with, say, patterns, so that the second time red comes around, it's dashed; the third time, dotted, etc. - but mod is just used to get red, green, blue, red, green, blue, forever.

Comments

5

Converting linear data structure to matrix structure: where a is index of linear data, and b is number of items per row:

row = a/b column = a mod b 

Note above is simplified logic: a must be offset -1 before dividing & the result must be normalized +1.

Example: (3 rows of 4)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 (7 - 1)/4 + 1 = 2 7 is in row 2 (7 - 1) mod 4 + 1 = 3 7 is in column 3 

Another common use of modulus: hashing a number by place. Suppose you wanted to store year & month in a six digit number 195810. month = 195810 mod 100 all digits 3rd from right are divisible by 100 so the remainder is the 2 rightmost digits in this case the month is 10. To extract the year 195810 / 100 yields 1958.

1 Comment

Why must you offset by 1?
4

Calculation of prime numbers

2 Comments

Although I haven't really found a situation where I actually needed to calculate them.
primes and thus modulo is heavily used in classical cryptography
4

The modulo can be useful to convert and split total minutes to "hours and minutes":

hours = minutes / 60

minutes_left = minutes % 60

In the hours bit we need to strip the decimal portion and that will depend on the language you are using.

We can then rearrange the output accordingly.

1 Comment

We can also use a modulus to find if a year is a leap year since it is divisible by 4. Example in JS: if (year % 4 === 0) { // it's a leap year }. (Note: a more accurate check will also verify divisibility by 100 and 400)
3

Modulus is also very useful if for some crazy reason you need to do integer division and get a decimal out, and you can't convert the integer into a number that supports decimal division, or if you need to return a fraction instead of a decimal.

I'll be using % as the modulus operator

For example

2/4 = 0

where doing this

2/4 = 0 and 2 % 4 = 2

So you can be really crazy and let's say that you want to allow the user to input a numerator and a divisor, and then show them the result as a whole number, and then a fractional number.

whole Number = numerator/divisor fractionNumerator = numerator % divisor fractionDenominator = divisor 

Another case where modulus division is useful is if you are increasing or decreasing a number and you want to contain the number to a certain range of number, but when you get to the top or bottom you don't want to just stop. You want to loop up to the bottom or top of the list respectively.

Imagine a function where you are looping through an array.

Function increase Or Decrease(variable As Integer) As Void n = (n + variable) % (listString.maxIndex + 1) Print listString[n] End Function 

The reason that it is n = (n + variable) % (listString.maxIndex + 1) is to allow for the max index to be accounted.

Those are just a few of the things that I have had to use modulus for in my programming of not just desktop applications, but in robotics and simulation environments.

Comments

2
  • Computing the greatest common divisor
  • Determining if a number is a palindrome
  • Determining if a number consists of only ...
  • Determining how many ... a number consists of...

Comments

2

My favorite use is for iteration.

Say you have a counter you are incrementing and want to then grab from a known list a corresponding items, but you only have n items to choose from and you want to repeat a cycle.

var indexFromB = (counter-1)%n+1;

Results (counter=indexFromB) given n=3:

`1=1` `2=2` `3=3` `4=1` `5=2` `6=3` ... 

Comments

2

Best use of modulus operator I have seen so for is to check if the Array we have is a rotated version of original array.

A = [1,2,3,4,5,6] B = [5,6,1,2,3,4]

Now how to check if B is rotated version of A ?

Step 1: If A's length is not same as B's length then for sure its not a rotated version.

Step 2: Check the index of first element of A in B. Here first element of A is 1. And its index in B is 2(assuming your programming language has zero based index). lets store that index in variable "Key"

Step 3: Now how to check that if B is rotated version of A how ??

This is where modulus function rocks :

for (int i = 0; i< A.length; i++) { // here modulus function would check the proper order. Key here is 2 which we recieved from Step 2 int j = [Key+i]%A.length; if (A[i] != B[j]) { return false; } } return true; 

Comments

1

It's an easy way to tell if a number is even or odd. Just do # mod 2, if it is 0 it is even, 1 it is odd.

Comments

1

Often, in a loop, you want to do something every k'th iteration, where k is 0 < k < n, assuming 0 is the start index and n is the length of the loop.

So, you'd do something like:

int k = 5; int n = 50; for(int i = 0;i < n;++i) { if(i % k == 0) // true at 0, 5, 10, 15.. { // do something } } 

Or, you want to keep something whitin a certain bound. Remember, when you take an arbitrary number mod something, it must produce a value between 0 and that number - 1.

Comments

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.