Return to Question

My intuition has always been that when any sphere is projected into 2D space that the result will always mathematically be an ellipse (or a circle in degenerate cases).

In the past when I was actively doing my own graphics programming and brought this up with other people they were adamant that I was wrong.

Who was correct?

Since there is already one answer submitted, I don't wish to totally change my question but I realize I left out an important factor.

I was interested only in perspective projection!

The other projections are of course interesting for many uses so I wouldn't want them removed at this point. But it would be great if answers could have perspective projection as their most prominent section.

My intuition has always been that when any sphere is projected into 2D space that the result will always mathematically be an ellipse (or a circle in degenerate cases).

In the past when I was actively doing my own graphics programming and brought this up with other people they were adamant that I was wrong. If I recall correctly they believed the result could be something vaguely "egg shaped".

Who was correct?

Since there is already one answer submitted, I don't wish to totally change my question but I realize I left out important details due to losing familiarity with the field over the years.

I intended to ask specifically about perspective projection where the projection is a linear application.

The other projections are of course interesting for many uses so I wouldn't want them removed at this point. But it would be great if answers could have perspective projection as their most prominent section.

My intuition has always been that when any sphere is projected into 2D space that the result will always mathematically be an ellipse (or a circle in degenerate cases).

In the past when I was actively doing my own graphics programming and brought this up with other people they were adamant that I was wrong.

Who was correct?

My intuition has always been that when any sphere is projected into 2D space that the result will always mathematically be an ellipse (or a circle in degenerate cases).

In the past when I was actively doing my own graphics programming and brought this up with other people they were adamant that I was wrong.

Who was correct?

Since there is already one answer submitted, I don't wish to totally change my question but I realize I left out an important factor.

I was interested only in perspective projection!

The other projections are of course interesting for many uses so I wouldn't want them removed at this point. But it would be great if answers could have perspective projection as their most prominent section.