Skip to main content
LaTeX fix
Source Link
Renan
  • 5.2k
  • 2
  • 29
  • 46

Assume ideal logic gates (no propagation delay) like this (image from wikipedia):

enter image description here

We know that the output of NOR gate is 1 if and only if both inputs are 0; and 0 otherwise.

When S = 1, Q = 1 and therefore \$\bar{Q} = 0\$; when R = 1, Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 1\$.

But if you set both R and S to 1 we have that Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 0\$ at the same time. This contradicts the relation \$Q = not Q\$\$Q = \bar{Q}\$. In the real world one of the gates will reach the 1 state first and the result will be unpredictable.

For the NAND-based RS flip-flop the same can be shown when R = S = 0, by writing the logic equations appropriately.

Assume ideal logic gates (no propagation delay) like this (image from wikipedia):

enter image description here

We know that the output of NOR gate is 1 if and only if both inputs are 0; and 0 otherwise.

When S = 1, Q = 1 and therefore \$\bar{Q} = 0\$; when R = 1, Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 1\$.

But if you set both R and S to 1 we have that Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 0\$ at the same time. This contradicts the relation \$Q = not Q\$. In the real world one of the gates will reach the 1 state first and the result will be unpredictable.

For the NAND-based RS flip-flop the same can be shown when R = S = 0, by writing the logic equations appropriately.

Assume ideal logic gates (no propagation delay) like this (image from wikipedia):

enter image description here

We know that the output of NOR gate is 1 if and only if both inputs are 0; and 0 otherwise.

When S = 1, Q = 1 and therefore \$\bar{Q} = 0\$; when R = 1, Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 1\$.

But if you set both R and S to 1 we have that Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 0\$ at the same time. This contradicts the relation \$Q = \bar{Q}\$. In the real world one of the gates will reach the 1 state first and the result will be unpredictable.

For the NAND-based RS flip-flop the same can be shown when R = S = 0, by writing the logic equations appropriately.

added 222 characters in body
Source Link
Renan
  • 5.2k
  • 2
  • 29
  • 46

Assume ideal logic gates (no propagation delay) like this (image from wikipedia):

enter image description here

We know that the output of NOR gate is 1 if and only if both inputs are 00; and 0 otherwise.

When S = 1, Q = 1 and therefore \$\bar{Q} = 0\$; when R = 1, Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 1\$.

But if you set both R and S to 1 we have that Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 0\$ at the same time. This contradicts the relation \$Q = not Q\$. In the real world one of the gates will reach the 1 state first and the result will be unpredictable.

For the NAND-based RS flip-flop the same can be shown when R = S = 0, by writing the logic equations appropriately.

Assume this (image from wikipedia):

enter image description here

We know that the output of NOR gate is 1 if both inputs are 0 and 0 otherwise.

When S = 1, Q = 1 and therefore \$\bar{Q} = 0\$; when R = 1, Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 1\$.

But if you set both R and S to 1 we have that Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 0\$ at the same time. This contradicts the relation \$Q = not Q\$.

For the NAND-based RS flip-flop the same can be shown.

Assume ideal logic gates (no propagation delay) like this (image from wikipedia):

enter image description here

We know that the output of NOR gate is 1 if and only if both inputs are 0; and 0 otherwise.

When S = 1, Q = 1 and therefore \$\bar{Q} = 0\$; when R = 1, Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 1\$.

But if you set both R and S to 1 we have that Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 0\$ at the same time. This contradicts the relation \$Q = not Q\$. In the real world one of the gates will reach the 1 state first and the result will be unpredictable.

For the NAND-based RS flip-flop the same can be shown when R = S = 0, by writing the logic equations appropriately.

Source Link
Renan
  • 5.2k
  • 2
  • 29
  • 46

Assume this (image from wikipedia):

enter image description here

We know that the output of NOR gate is 1 if both inputs are 0 and 0 otherwise.

When S = 1, Q = 1 and therefore \$\bar{Q} = 0\$; when R = 1, Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 1\$.

But if you set both R and S to 1 we have that Q = 0 and \$\bar{Q} = 0\$ at the same time. This contradicts the relation \$Q = not Q\$.

For the NAND-based RS flip-flop the same can be shown.