Skip to main content
Mathematics

Return to Answer

Commonmark migration
Source Link
Community Bot
Community Bot
  • 1

Migration

###Migration ItIt sounds like the closure process for newly migrated questions needs some adjustment. The best thing would probably to have a special closure reason "should not have been migrated here from wherever and should be sent back", which would have this special effect none of the others should have.

Moderator votes

###Moderator votes II don't really see too many reasons for moderators to have extra votes with regard to the usual closure/reopening process. If the post absolutely must be shut down right now without delay (e.g., contest question), they can just delete it. Otherwise, just let them have a single vote to participate like everyone else. The only exception I can think of is to deal with a question that was closed for the wrong reason, in particular when it should have been closed as a duplicate, but I would argue that the best solution to that problem would be to allow normal users to vote to change the closure reason on a closed question to duplicate.

Unfortunately, I doubt either of these suggestions have any hope of becoming reality.

###Migration It sounds like the closure process for newly migrated questions needs some adjustment. The best thing would probably to have a special closure reason "should not have been migrated here from wherever and should be sent back", which would have this special effect none of the others should have.

###Moderator votes I don't really see too many reasons for moderators to have extra votes with regard to the usual closure/reopening process. If the post absolutely must be shut down right now without delay (e.g., contest question), they can just delete it. Otherwise, just let them have a single vote to participate like everyone else. The only exception I can think of is to deal with a question that was closed for the wrong reason, in particular when it should have been closed as a duplicate, but I would argue that the best solution to that problem would be to allow normal users to vote to change the closure reason on a closed question to duplicate.

Unfortunately, I doubt either of these suggestions have any hope of becoming reality.

Migration

It sounds like the closure process for newly migrated questions needs some adjustment. The best thing would probably to have a special closure reason "should not have been migrated here from wherever and should be sent back", which would have this special effect none of the others should have.

Moderator votes

I don't really see too many reasons for moderators to have extra votes with regard to the usual closure/reopening process. If the post absolutely must be shut down right now without delay (e.g., contest question), they can just delete it. Otherwise, just let them have a single vote to participate like everyone else. The only exception I can think of is to deal with a question that was closed for the wrong reason, in particular when it should have been closed as a duplicate, but I would argue that the best solution to that problem would be to allow normal users to vote to change the closure reason on a closed question to duplicate.

Unfortunately, I doubt either of these suggestions have any hope of becoming reality.

Source Link
dfeuer
dfeuer
  • 9.4k
  • 18
  • 26

###Migration It sounds like the closure process for newly migrated questions needs some adjustment. The best thing would probably to have a special closure reason "should not have been migrated here from wherever and should be sent back", which would have this special effect none of the others should have.

###Moderator votes I don't really see too many reasons for moderators to have extra votes with regard to the usual closure/reopening process. If the post absolutely must be shut down right now without delay (e.g., contest question), they can just delete it. Otherwise, just let them have a single vote to participate like everyone else. The only exception I can think of is to deal with a question that was closed for the wrong reason, in particular when it should have been closed as a duplicate, but I would argue that the best solution to that problem would be to allow normal users to vote to change the closure reason on a closed question to duplicate.

Unfortunately, I doubt either of these suggestions have any hope of becoming reality.