Skip to main content
Notice removed Authoritative reference needed by Pranoy Ray
Bounty Ended with Phil Hasnip's answer chosen by Pranoy Ray
deleted 477 characters in body
Source Link
Pranoy Ray
  • 1.6k
  • 4
  • 22

The range of properties I have access to are the following:

spg_number, formation_energy_peratom, optb88vdw_bandgap, magmom_oszicar, elastic_tensor, effective_masses_300K, kpoint_length_unit, maxdiff_mesh, maxdiff_bz, encut, optb88vdw_total_energy, epsx, epsy, epsz, mepsx, mepsy, mepsz, modes, magmom_outcar, max_efg, avg_elec_mass, avg_hole_mass, icsd, dfpt_piezo_max_eij, dfpt_piezo_max_dij, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_electronic, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_ionic, max_ir_mode, min_ir_mode, n-Seebeck, p-Seebeck, n-powerfact, p-powerfact, ncond, pcond, nkappa, pkappa, ehull, Tc_supercon, dimensionality, efg, typ, crys, density, poisson, bulk_modulus_kv, shear_modulus_gv, mbj_bandgap, hse_gap.

  1. SPG
  2. Formation Energy per Atom
  3. Total (Relaxed) Energy per Atom
  4. BandGap
  5. Elastic Tensor
  6. Magnetic Moment (OSZICAR & OUTCAR)
  7. Energy above Hull
  8. Bulk Modulus
  9. Shear Modulus
  10. Poisson's Ratio
  11. Superconducting transition temperature (Tc)
  12. mBJ BandGap

From the above list, I can ascertain that the Bulk Modulus and ECD are directly related by the Birch-Murnaghan Equation of State, but when we talk about the Total Energy (relaxed) of the system, it is dependent on a bunch of other factors other than the charge density like the Exchange correlation potential, as a result, Total Energy is not a desirable answer as it does not necessarily depend on the ECD only but also on $E_{xc}$. Considering the CHGCAR file as the only piece of information I have, what are the properties that can be directly connected to CHGCAR?

Note: I am not talking about the CHGCAR difference. I have just one converged CHGCAR for every material.

The range of properties I have access to are the following:

spg_number, formation_energy_peratom, optb88vdw_bandgap, magmom_oszicar, elastic_tensor, effective_masses_300K, kpoint_length_unit, maxdiff_mesh, maxdiff_bz, encut, optb88vdw_total_energy, epsx, epsy, epsz, mepsx, mepsy, mepsz, modes, magmom_outcar, max_efg, avg_elec_mass, avg_hole_mass, icsd, dfpt_piezo_max_eij, dfpt_piezo_max_dij, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_electronic, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_ionic, max_ir_mode, min_ir_mode, n-Seebeck, p-Seebeck, n-powerfact, p-powerfact, ncond, pcond, nkappa, pkappa, ehull, Tc_supercon, dimensionality, efg, typ, crys, density, poisson, bulk_modulus_kv, shear_modulus_gv, mbj_bandgap, hse_gap.

From the above list, I can ascertain that the Bulk Modulus and ECD are directly related by the Birch-Murnaghan Equation of State, but when we talk about the Total Energy (relaxed) of the system, it is dependent on a bunch of other factors other than the charge density like the Exchange correlation potential, as a result, Total Energy is not a desirable answer as it does not necessarily depend on the ECD only but also on $E_{xc}$. Considering the CHGCAR file as the only piece of information I have, what are the properties that can be directly connected to CHGCAR?

Note: I am not talking about the CHGCAR difference. I have just one converged CHGCAR for every material.

The range of properties I have access to are the following:

  1. SPG
  2. Formation Energy per Atom
  3. Total (Relaxed) Energy per Atom
  4. BandGap
  5. Elastic Tensor
  6. Magnetic Moment (OSZICAR & OUTCAR)
  7. Energy above Hull
  8. Bulk Modulus
  9. Shear Modulus
  10. Poisson's Ratio
  11. Superconducting transition temperature (Tc)
  12. mBJ BandGap

From the above list, I can ascertain that the Bulk Modulus and ECD are directly related by the Birch-Murnaghan Equation of State, but when we talk about the Total Energy (relaxed) of the system, it is dependent on a bunch of other factors other than the charge density like the Exchange correlation potential, as a result, Total Energy is not a desirable answer as it does not necessarily depend on the ECD only but also on $E_{xc}$. Considering the CHGCAR file as the only piece of information I have, what are the properties that can be directly connected to CHGCAR?

Note: I am not talking about the CHGCAR difference. I have just one converged CHGCAR for every material.

deleted 11 characters in body
Source Link
Pranoy Ray
  • 1.6k
  • 4
  • 22

The range of properties I have access to are the following:

spg_number, formula, formation_energy_peratom, optb88vdw_bandgap, magmom_oszicar, elastic_tensor, effective_masses_300K, kpoint_length_unit, maxdiff_mesh, maxdiff_bz, encut, optb88vdw_total_energy, epsx, epsy, epsz, mepsx, mepsy, mepsz, modes, magmom_outcar, max_efg, avg_elec_mass, avg_hole_mass, icsd, dfpt_piezo_max_eij, dfpt_piezo_max_dij, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_electronic, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_ionic, max_ir_mode, min_ir_mode, n-Seebeck, p-Seebeck, n-powerfact, p-powerfact, ncond, pcond, nkappa, pkappa, ehull, Tc_supercon, dimensionality, efg, typ, crys, density, poisson, bulk_modulus_kv, shear_modulus_gv, mbj_bandgap, hse_gap.

From the above list, I can ascertain that the Bulk Modulus and ECD are directly related by the Birch-Murnaghan Equation of State, but when we talk about the Total Energy (relaxed) of the system, it is dependent on a bunch of other factors other than the charge density like the Exchange correlation potential, as a result, Total Energy is not a desirable answer as it does not necessarily depend on the ECD only but also on $E_{xc}$. Considering the CHGCAR file as the only piece of information I have, what are the properties that can be directly connected to CHGCAR?

Note: I am not talking about the CHGCAR difference. I have just one converged CHGCAR for every material.

The range of properties I have access to are the following:

spg_number, formula, formation_energy_peratom, optb88vdw_bandgap, magmom_oszicar, elastic_tensor, effective_masses_300K, kpoint_length_unit, maxdiff_mesh, maxdiff_bz, encut, optb88vdw_total_energy, epsx, epsy, epsz, mepsx, mepsy, mepsz, modes, magmom_outcar, max_efg, avg_elec_mass, avg_hole_mass, icsd, dfpt_piezo_max_eij, dfpt_piezo_max_dij, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_electronic, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_ionic, max_ir_mode, min_ir_mode, n-Seebeck, p-Seebeck, n-powerfact, p-powerfact, ncond, pcond, nkappa, pkappa, ehull, Tc_supercon, dimensionality, efg, typ, crys, density, poisson, bulk_modulus_kv, shear_modulus_gv, mbj_bandgap, hse_gap.

From the above list, I can ascertain that the Bulk Modulus and ECD are directly related by the Birch-Murnaghan Equation of State, but when we talk about the Total Energy (relaxed) of the system, it is dependent on a bunch of other factors other than the charge density like the Exchange correlation potential, as a result, Total Energy is not a desirable answer as it does not necessarily depend on the ECD only but also on $E_{xc}$. Considering the CHGCAR file as the only piece of information I have, what are the properties that can be directly connected to CHGCAR?

Note: I am not talking about the CHGCAR difference. I have just one converged CHGCAR for every material.

The range of properties I have access to are the following:

spg_number, formation_energy_peratom, optb88vdw_bandgap, magmom_oszicar, elastic_tensor, effective_masses_300K, kpoint_length_unit, maxdiff_mesh, maxdiff_bz, encut, optb88vdw_total_energy, epsx, epsy, epsz, mepsx, mepsy, mepsz, modes, magmom_outcar, max_efg, avg_elec_mass, avg_hole_mass, icsd, dfpt_piezo_max_eij, dfpt_piezo_max_dij, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_electronic, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_ionic, max_ir_mode, min_ir_mode, n-Seebeck, p-Seebeck, n-powerfact, p-powerfact, ncond, pcond, nkappa, pkappa, ehull, Tc_supercon, dimensionality, efg, typ, crys, density, poisson, bulk_modulus_kv, shear_modulus_gv, mbj_bandgap, hse_gap.

From the above list, I can ascertain that the Bulk Modulus and ECD are directly related by the Birch-Murnaghan Equation of State, but when we talk about the Total Energy (relaxed) of the system, it is dependent on a bunch of other factors other than the charge density like the Exchange correlation potential, as a result, Total Energy is not a desirable answer as it does not necessarily depend on the ECD only but also on $E_{xc}$. Considering the CHGCAR file as the only piece of information I have, what are the properties that can be directly connected to CHGCAR?

Note: I am not talking about the CHGCAR difference. I have just one converged CHGCAR for every material.

Notice added Authoritative reference needed by Pranoy Ray
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Pranoy Ray
added 4 characters in body
Source Link
Pranoy Ray
  • 1.6k
  • 4
  • 22

The range of properties I have access to are the following:

spg_number, formula, formation_energy_peratom, optb88vdw_bandgap, magmom_oszicar, elastic_tensor, effective_masses_300K, kpoint_length_unit, maxdiff_mesh, maxdiff_bz, encut, optb88vdw_total_energy, epsx, epsy, epsz, mepsx, mepsy, mepsz, modes, magmom_outcar, max_efg, avg_elec_mass, avg_hole_mass, icsd, dfpt_piezo_max_eij, dfpt_piezo_max_dij, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_electronic, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_ionic, max_ir_mode, min_ir_mode, n-Seebeck, p-Seebeck, n-powerfact, p-powerfact, ncond, pcond, nkappa, pkappa, ehull, Tc_supercon, dimensionality, efg, typ, crys, density, poisson, bulk_modulus_kv, shear_modulus_gv, mbj_bandgap, hse_gap.

From the above list, I can ascertain that the Bulk Modulus and ECD are directly related by the Birch-Murnaghan Equation of State, but when we talk about the Total Energy (relaxed) of the system, it is dependent on a bunch of other factors other than the charge density like the Exchange correlation potential, as a result, Total Energy is not a desirable answer as it does not necessarily depend on the ECD only but also on $E_{xc}$. Considering the CHGCAR file as the only piece of information I have, what are the properties that can be directly connected to CHGCAR?

Note: I am not talking about the CHGCAR difference. I have just one converged CHGCAR for every material.

The range of properties I have access to are the following:

spg_number, formula, formation_energy_peratom, optb88vdw_bandgap, magmom_oszicar, elastic_tensor, effective_masses_300K, kpoint_length_unit, maxdiff_mesh, maxdiff_bz, encut, optb88vdw_total_energy, epsx, epsy, epsz, mepsx, mepsy, mepsz, modes, magmom_outcar, max_efg, avg_elec_mass, avg_hole_mass, icsd, dfpt_piezo_max_eij, dfpt_piezo_max_dij, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_electronic, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_ionic, max_ir_mode, min_ir_mode, n-Seebeck, p-Seebeck, n-powerfact, p-powerfact, ncond, pcond, nkappa, pkappa, ehull, Tc_supercon, dimensionality, efg, typ, crys, density, poisson, bulk_modulus_kv, shear_modulus_gv, mbj_bandgap, hse_gap.

From the above list, I can ascertain that the Bulk Modulus and ECD are directly related by the Birch-Murnaghan Equation of State, but when we talk about the Total Energy (relaxed) of the system, it is dependent on a bunch of other factors other than the charge density like the Exchange correlation potential, as a result, Total Energy is not a desirable answer as it does not necessarily depend on the ECD only but also on $E_{xc}$. Considering the CHGCAR file as the only piece of information I have, what are the properties that can be directly connected to CHGCAR?

Note: I am talking about the CHGCAR difference. I have just one converged CHGCAR for every material.

The range of properties I have access to are the following:

spg_number, formula, formation_energy_peratom, optb88vdw_bandgap, magmom_oszicar, elastic_tensor, effective_masses_300K, kpoint_length_unit, maxdiff_mesh, maxdiff_bz, encut, optb88vdw_total_energy, epsx, epsy, epsz, mepsx, mepsy, mepsz, modes, magmom_outcar, max_efg, avg_elec_mass, avg_hole_mass, icsd, dfpt_piezo_max_eij, dfpt_piezo_max_dij, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_electronic, dfpt_piezo_max_dielectric_ionic, max_ir_mode, min_ir_mode, n-Seebeck, p-Seebeck, n-powerfact, p-powerfact, ncond, pcond, nkappa, pkappa, ehull, Tc_supercon, dimensionality, efg, typ, crys, density, poisson, bulk_modulus_kv, shear_modulus_gv, mbj_bandgap, hse_gap.

From the above list, I can ascertain that the Bulk Modulus and ECD are directly related by the Birch-Murnaghan Equation of State, but when we talk about the Total Energy (relaxed) of the system, it is dependent on a bunch of other factors other than the charge density like the Exchange correlation potential, as a result, Total Energy is not a desirable answer as it does not necessarily depend on the ECD only but also on $E_{xc}$. Considering the CHGCAR file as the only piece of information I have, what are the properties that can be directly connected to CHGCAR?

Note: I am not talking about the CHGCAR difference. I have just one converged CHGCAR for every material.

added 104 characters in body
Source Link
Pranoy Ray
  • 1.6k
  • 4
  • 22
Loading
code formatting, typo correction
Source Link
AbdulMuhaymin
  • 4.9k
  • 2
  • 14
  • 46
Loading
Source Link
Pranoy Ray
  • 1.6k
  • 4
  • 22
Loading