Skip to main content
Question Unprotected by Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog
Question Protected by Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog
Add the word "reconsider" so that searching for that word and forms turns up this question
Source Link

As I was browsing earlier today, I really happened to like an answer to a question. The question didn't interest me so much, and the answer was actually a tangential reply to some of the comments in the post, and was by far more valuable than the original question or the accepted answer. Now, my only options to favorite that answer are

  1. Favorite the question.
  2. Add the link to the answer to my browser's bookmarks.

I was pretty sure others have had the need for this, and sure enough, I found a discussion and a feature-request, both nearly two years ago and a denial of said request, nearly a year ago.

Now, there might have been several reasons why it (and several other old feature-requests) was denied. SO was pretty young back then, there probably weren't enough developers on board, perhaps they didn't have the resources to track favorite answers. But SO has grown since then from 1-3 sites to 30+ sites. Requests that might have at one point been too demanding, might now be easily implementable, which could greatly enhance user experience.

So, my question is: "Can we re-request features that were previously declined, provided the request and the denial are sufficiently old, so that the team can reconsider their decision?"

After how long is sufficient enough needs to be decided by the community and is only to prevent re-requesting a feature that was only declined say a week ago.

As I was browsing earlier today, I really happened to like an answer to a question. The question didn't interest me so much, and the answer was actually a tangential reply to some of the comments in the post, and was by far more valuable than the original question or the accepted answer. Now, my only options to favorite that answer are

  1. Favorite the question.
  2. Add the link to the answer to my browser's bookmarks.

I was pretty sure others have had the need for this, and sure enough, I found a discussion and a feature-request, both nearly two years ago and a denial of said request, nearly a year ago.

Now, there might have been several reasons why it (and several other old feature-requests) was denied. SO was pretty young back then, there probably weren't enough developers on board, perhaps they didn't have the resources to track favorite answers. But SO has grown since then from 1-3 sites to 30+ sites. Requests that might have at one point been too demanding, might now be easily implementable, which could greatly enhance user experience.

So, my question is: "Can we re-request features that were previously declined, provided the request and the denial are sufficiently old?"

After how long is sufficient enough needs to be decided by the community and is only to prevent re-requesting a feature that was only declined say a week ago.

As I was browsing earlier today, I really happened to like an answer to a question. The question didn't interest me so much, and the answer was actually a tangential reply to some of the comments in the post, and was by far more valuable than the original question or the accepted answer. Now, my only options to favorite that answer are

  1. Favorite the question.
  2. Add the link to the answer to my browser's bookmarks.

I was pretty sure others have had the need for this, and sure enough, I found a discussion and a feature-request, both nearly two years ago and a denial of said request, nearly a year ago.

Now, there might have been several reasons why it (and several other old feature-requests) was denied. SO was pretty young back then, there probably weren't enough developers on board, perhaps they didn't have the resources to track favorite answers. But SO has grown since then from 1-3 sites to 30+ sites. Requests that might have at one point been too demanding, might now be easily implementable, which could greatly enhance user experience.

So, my question is: "Can we re-request features that were previously declined, provided the request and the denial are sufficiently old, so that the team can reconsider their decision?"

After how long is sufficient enough needs to be decided by the community and is only to prevent re-requesting a feature that was only declined say a week ago.

replaced http://meta.stackexchange.com/ with https://meta.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

As I was browsing earlier today, I really happened to like an answer to a question. The question didn't interest me so much, and the answer was actually a tangential reply to some of the comments in the post, and was by far more valuable than the original question or the accepted answer. Now, my only options to favorite that answer are

  1. Favorite the question.
  2. Add the link to the answer to my browser's bookmarks.

I was pretty sure others have had the need for this, and sure enough, I found a discussiondiscussion and a feature-requestfeature-request, both nearly two years ago and a denial of said requestdenial of said request, nearly a year ago.

Now, there might have been several reasons why it (and several other old feature-requests) was denied. SO was pretty young back then, there probably weren't enough developers on board, perhaps they didn't have the resources to track favorite answers. But SO has grown since then from 1-3 sites to 30+ sites. Requests that might have at one point been too demanding, might now be easily implementable, which could greatly enhance user experience.

So, my question is: "Can we re-request features that were previously declined, provided the request and the denial are sufficiently old?"

After how long is sufficient enough needs to be decided by the community and is only to prevent re-requesting a feature that was only declined say a week ago.

As I was browsing earlier today, I really happened to like an answer to a question. The question didn't interest me so much, and the answer was actually a tangential reply to some of the comments in the post, and was by far more valuable than the original question or the accepted answer. Now, my only options to favorite that answer are

  1. Favorite the question.
  2. Add the link to the answer to my browser's bookmarks.

I was pretty sure others have had the need for this, and sure enough, I found a discussion and a feature-request, both nearly two years ago and a denial of said request, nearly a year ago.

Now, there might have been several reasons why it (and several other old feature-requests) was denied. SO was pretty young back then, there probably weren't enough developers on board, perhaps they didn't have the resources to track favorite answers. But SO has grown since then from 1-3 sites to 30+ sites. Requests that might have at one point been too demanding, might now be easily implementable, which could greatly enhance user experience.

So, my question is: "Can we re-request features that were previously declined, provided the request and the denial are sufficiently old?"

After how long is sufficient enough needs to be decided by the community and is only to prevent re-requesting a feature that was only declined say a week ago.

As I was browsing earlier today, I really happened to like an answer to a question. The question didn't interest me so much, and the answer was actually a tangential reply to some of the comments in the post, and was by far more valuable than the original question or the accepted answer. Now, my only options to favorite that answer are

  1. Favorite the question.
  2. Add the link to the answer to my browser's bookmarks.

I was pretty sure others have had the need for this, and sure enough, I found a discussion and a feature-request, both nearly two years ago and a denial of said request, nearly a year ago.

Now, there might have been several reasons why it (and several other old feature-requests) was denied. SO was pretty young back then, there probably weren't enough developers on board, perhaps they didn't have the resources to track favorite answers. But SO has grown since then from 1-3 sites to 30+ sites. Requests that might have at one point been too demanding, might now be easily implementable, which could greatly enhance user experience.

So, my question is: "Can we re-request features that were previously declined, provided the request and the denial are sufficiently old?"

After how long is sufficient enough needs to be decided by the community and is only to prevent re-requesting a feature that was only declined say a week ago.

Fixup of bad MSO links to MSE links migration
Source Link
Loading
Fixup of bad MSO links to MSE links migration
Source Link
Loading
Migration of MSO links to MSE links
Source Link
Loading
Bounty Ended with forsvarir's answer chosen by Daniel DiPaolo
Bounty Started worth 100 reputation by Daniel DiPaolo
Source Link
Lorem Ipsum
  • 23.5k
  • 8
  • 64
  • 115
Loading