Bone Valley: A True Story of Injustice and Redemption in the Heart of Florida, by Gilbert King

It was August 2017 when author/photographer/investigator Gilbert King made his way to Naples, Florida. He was slated to deliver the keynote address to the Florida Conference of Circuit Judges, which was taking place at a venue in that city. During a lunch break, as King was chatting with some of the judges, a man approached and handed him a business card. On the back of the card was written the following:
LEO SCHOFIELD #115760 HARDEE C.I.
NOT JUST “WRONGFULLY CONVICTED,”
HE’S AN INNOCENT MAN.
As the man walked away, he turned to King and indicated that he should call him.
As summarized on Gilbert King’s website, here is how matters stood:
‘In 1988, 22-year-old Leo Schofield—a heavy metal guitarist from Lakeland, Florida—was arrested and charged with the murder of his 18-year-old wife, Michelle. Leo maintained his innocence from the beginning, but he was failed at nearly every turn: the investigation was shoddy, the defense inadequate, and critical evidence was overlooked. Convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison, Leo exhausted his appeals and seemed destined to remain in the shadows.’
Author of the Pulitzer-Prize winning narrative Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America, a Pulitzer-Prize winning narrative, as well as Beneath a Ruthless Sun: A True Story of Violence, Race, and Justice Lost and Found, Gilbert King was a busy man with a full schedule; nevertheless, he was immediately intrigued by this situation. He followed up on the lead he’d been given. The result was a podcast, the exoneration of a wrongly imprisoned man, and ultimately the book Bone Valley.
Highly, highly recommended.

Transcription by Kate Atkinson

‘”Mr Toby! Mr. Toby!”‘
A chance encounter on a London street causes Juliet Armstrong call out excitedly to a man she’s sure she recognizes – someone she worked beside in ‘the old days.’ But Godfrey Toby frostily informs her that she must be mistaken – he does not know her, has never seen her before. Juliet is bewildered. Why would he refuse to acknowledge her? It must have to do with their former employment….
For Juliet and Godfrey Toby worked in Intelligence, during the Second World War. They were installed in an apartment directly adjacent to where a cell of collaborators were busy passing information to the enemy. Juliet’s group secretly recorded their conversations; it was Juliet’s task to generate transcriptions of these forbidden revelations.
Type, type, type…
Juliet came to join this operation at a very young age. She was guileless and naive, at the time. As she burrows deeply into her remit, this changes. Unavoidably, her mindset alters, and her whole life changes.
‘Juliet had been easy to recruit. She had believed in fairness and equality, in justice and truth. She believed that England could be a better country. She was the apple ripe for plucking and she had also been Eve willing to eat the apple. The endless dialectic between innocence and experience.’
Kate Atkinson is an author I have long admired. An early novel, Case Histories, was hugely entertaining and highly irreverent. Then came Life Histories, a completely different kind of a novel, on a grand scale, profound and riveting.
Transcription boasts that rarity in contemporary fiction: a terrific conclusion. In fact, the whole novel is terrific – I loved it!
;

