Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/StackSecurity/status/821941589761212420
added 129 characters in body
Source Link
Arminius
  • 45.2k
  • 12
  • 30

We currently have 82 questions, over 60% of them got closed.

As and are the tags with the highest ratio of closed questions, it seems to be unclear to askers what we expect from a good question about learning and working in the security field. Not all of them were poorly received but I suspect that even somesome better ones ones would today get closed as opinion-based or too broad rather quickly.

The tag guidance ("A career is a chosen occupation or profession..." - well, duh) also isn't incredibly helpful. I'd improve it myself but I'm unsure what actually makes a good career question, since career choices seem inherently opinion-based.

We currently have 82 questions, over 60% of them got closed.

As and are the tags with the highest ratio of closed questions, it seems to be unclear what we expect from a good question about learning and working in the security field. Not all of them were poorly received but I suspect that even some better ones would today get closed as opinion-based rather quickly.

The tag guidance ("A career is a chosen occupation or profession..." - well, duh) also isn't incredibly helpful. I'd improve it myself but I'm unsure what actually makes a good career question, since career choices seem inherently opinion-based.

We currently have 82 questions, over 60% of them got closed.

As and are the tags with the highest ratio of closed questions, it seems to be unclear to askers what we expect from a good question about learning and working in the security field. Not all of them were poorly received but I suspect that even some better ones would today get closed as opinion-based or too broad rather quickly.

The tag guidance ("A career is a chosen occupation or profession..." - well, duh) also isn't incredibly helpful. I'd improve it myself but I'm unsure what actually makes a good career question, since career choices seem inherently opinion-based.

added 40 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Arminius
  • 45.2k
  • 12
  • 30

What ismakes a good [career] question?

We currently have 82 questions, over 60% of them got closed.

As and are the tags with the highest ratio of closed questions, it seems to be unclear what we expect from a good question about learning and working in the security field. Not all of them are bad questionswere poorly received but I suspect that even thesome better ones would probably today beget closed as opinion-based rather quickly.

The tag infoguidance ("A career is a chosen occupation or profession..." - well, duh) also isn't incredibly helpful. I'd improve it myself but I'm unsure about what what actually makes a good career question as, since career choices seem inherently opinion-based.

What is a good [career] question?

We currently have 82 questions, over 60% of them got closed.

As and are the tags with the highest ratio of closed questions, it seems to be unclear what we expect from a good question about learning and working in the security field. Not all of them are bad questions but even the better ones would probably today be closed as opinion-based.

The tag info ("A career is a chosen occupation or profession...") also isn't incredibly helpful. I'd improve it myself but I'm unsure about what actually makes a good career question as career choices seem inherently opinion-based.

What makes a good [career] question?

We currently have 82 questions, over 60% of them got closed.

As and are the tags with the highest ratio of closed questions, it seems to be unclear what we expect from a good question about learning and working in the security field. Not all of them were poorly received but I suspect that even some better ones would today get closed as opinion-based rather quickly.

The tag guidance ("A career is a chosen occupation or profession..." - well, duh) also isn't incredibly helpful. I'd improve it myself but I'm unsure what actually makes a good career question, since career choices seem inherently opinion-based.

added 9 characters in body
Source Link
Arminius
  • 45.2k
  • 12
  • 30

We currently have 82 questions, over 60% of them got closed.

As and are the tags with the highest ratio of closed questions, it seems to be unclear what we expect from a good question about learning and working in the security field. Not all of them are bad questions but even the better ones would probably today be closed as opinion-based.

The tag info ("A career is a chosen occupation or profession...") also isn't incredibly helpful. I'd improve it myself but I'm unsure about what actually makes a good career question as career choices seem inherently opinion-based.

We currently have 82 questions, over 60% of them got closed.

As and are the tags with the highest ratio of closed questions, it seems to be unclear what we expect from a good question about learning and working in the field. Not all of them are bad questions but even the better ones would probably today be closed as opinion-based.

The tag info ("A career is a chosen occupation or profession...") also isn't incredibly helpful. I'd improve it myself but I'm unsure about what actually makes a good career question as career choices seem inherently opinion-based.

We currently have 82 questions, over 60% of them got closed.

As and are the tags with the highest ratio of closed questions, it seems to be unclear what we expect from a good question about learning and working in the security field. Not all of them are bad questions but even the better ones would probably today be closed as opinion-based.

The tag info ("A career is a chosen occupation or profession...") also isn't incredibly helpful. I'd improve it myself but I'm unsure about what actually makes a good career question as career choices seem inherently opinion-based.

Source Link
Arminius
  • 45.2k
  • 12
  • 30
Loading