1

So I know that in Java when you have a static method you are supposed to call it with the format ClassName.method() rather than use the same structure as you would for instance methods, namely:

ClassName myObject = new ClassName(); myObject.method();

However, if you were to do it this way it would still be valid code and would work. Let's say I decide to do this where the method in question is static, and have the following setup:

public SuperClass { public static int foo(int x) { return x; } } public SubClass extends SuperClass { public static int foo(int x) { // Overriding foo() in SuperClass return x + 1; } } public MyDriver { public static void main(String[] args) { SuperClass myObject = new SubClass(); // Upcasting. System.out.println(myObject.foo(5)); // This should polymorphically print 6 } }

What prints out on the screen, however, is 5 rather than 6. Why?

Improve this question

4 Answers 4

Reset to default
5

Static methods apply only to the class they are defined in, and they cannot be overridden.

When you call myObject.foo(5), you are calling SuperClass.foo(5) in reality, because you declared myObject as a SuperClass, regardless of whether you instantiated it as one.

The proper way to call a static method is to call it directly from the class it is declared in, so if you wanted to call SubClass.foo(), you must call it from an explicitly declared SubClass instance (meaning no upcasting), or you need to call SubClass.foo() like so.

The simple answer is that calling static methods from instances evaluates to calling those same methods from the declared type with no instance rather than the instance type.

I am not certain of this, but I would not be surprised if when the code is compiled into byte-code, that the instance static method call would actually be compiled into a direct call to the declared type.

Edit: An upvote brought my attention back to this and I cleaned up the explanation to make it more clear and fix some negligible grammatical mistakes on my part. I hope this helps future readers.

Improve this answer
Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

Comments

1

Using instances of a class to call that class's static methods is something you should avoid, since it can cause confusion. If you need to call any method polymorphically, make it an instance method. You cannot polymorphically call a static method. The reason the SuperClass invocation is called is because that is the apparent class of myObject at compile-time. This effect can also be seen in the following scenario:

public void doSomething(SuperClass param) { System.out.println("SuperClass"); } public void doSomething(SubClass param) { System.out.println("SubClass"); } public void test() { SuperClass myObject = new SubClass(); doSomething(myObject); }

If test() is called, SuperClass will be printed.

Improve this answer

Comments

1

Static methods don't depends on the instance, they belong to the class and only to the class, in fact if you have a static method you'll always access to one unique instance always.

 myObject.foo(5)

is only a shortcut, what you really are doing is

 SuperClass.foo(5)
Improve this answer

2 Comments

It's not really only one instance, it's one per virtual machine if you have more than one virtual machine you may have more than one instance.
+1 but depending on ClassLoader architecture it could even be more than one per JVM; OSGi for example.
0

Static methods are treated as global by the JVM, they are not bound to an object instance at all. By the way, you can only overload static methods, but you can not override. So check for "Oracle Documentation for Overriding and Hiding Documents".

Defining a Method with the Same Signature as a Superclass's Method:

-----------------------------------------Superclass Instance MethodSuperclass Static Method   
Subclass Instance Method      Overrides                                     Generates a compile-time error
Subclass Static Method            Generates a compile-time error   Hides                                         

Improve this answer

Comments

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.