Assuming that the suggested edit is good enough that you would consider accepting it, based on its own merits, and ignoring the comment, here’s a possible approach: The first time you see something like this: 1. Accept the edit (or improve it). 2. Leave a comment for the editor asking him to write better comments. (You can @-ping people who have (successfully) edited a post. But you’ll have to type (or copy and paste) the user’s name, because it isn’t included in the auto-complete. And this doesn’t work at all for users who have suggested edits that were rejected.) 3. Make a note of the user name. Then, when you more low-quality edit comments coming from the same users, reject them.