0
$\begingroup$

Background

Let's say we have a tetrahedron spanned by the points $A(0, 0, 0), B(5, 0, 0), C(4, 2, 0), T(0, 0, 5)$, and we want to find the volume.

Scenario 1

Ok, one way to do it is to use $\triangle ABC$ as base, and then $AT$ becomes the height of the triangle, since A is the closes point to T on the base. We can then use the formula for the volume of a pyramid, and we get $$V = \frac13 Bh = \frac13\left( \overbrace{\frac12|\vec{AB}\times\vec{AC}|}^{\text{area of triangle base}}\right) \cdot \overbrace{|\vec{AT}|}^{\text{height of figure}} = \frac{25}3$$

Now here, I got "lucky" because $\vec{AT}$ happens to already be the height of the tetrahedron. I didn't have to find the height by connecting the top to the closest point in the triangle base.

Scenario 2

Let's use $\triangle BCT$ as the base, and $A$ as the top.

By the formula for the volume of a tetrahedron with vectors, we get

$$V = \frac16 \left| \overbrace{ \left(\vec{BC} \times \vec{BT}\right)}^{\text{area of triangle base, but 1/2 is accounted for in 1/6}} \cdot \overbrace{\vec{BA}}^{\color{red}{\text{not height of figure}}}\right| = \ldots = \frac{25}{3}$$

Question

In the last scenario, I see that the $\frac16$ arrives by $\frac13$ from the volume of a pyramid, times $\frac12$ from the area of the triangle base. But how come we could just use $\vec{BA}$ like that? It's not the height of the tetrahedron, if we consider $\triangle BCT$ as the base.

From what I can tell, $|\vec{BA}| = 5$ while the distance from $A$ to $\triangle BCT$ is $\frac{10}3$.

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

1
$\begingroup$

$\vec{s}=\vec{BC}\times\vec{BT}$ is a vector perpendicular to plane $BCT$.

$\vec{s}\cdot\vec{BA}$ is $|\vec{s}|$ times the projection of $\vec{BA}$ upon $\vec{s}$, which is the height relative to base $BCT$.

$\endgroup$
1
  • $\begingroup$ Right, it looks like I was conflating the effect of the scalar product with scalar multiplication. $\endgroup$ Commented May 25, 2023 at 11:25

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.