0
$\begingroup$

I'm confused about how to interpret the given conditions of this problem.

"An insurance policy pays for a random loss $X$ subject to a deductible of $C$ where $0<C<1$. The loss amount is modeled as a continuous random variable with density function $$f(x) = \begin{cases}2x~~ 0<x<1 \\ 0~~\text{otherwise}\end{cases}$$ $\textbf{Given a random loss $X$}$ the probability that the insurance payment is less than .5 is .64. Calculate $C$."

The phrase "given a random loss $X$" suggested to me that .64 was equal to a conditional probability involving $X$. But according to the posted solution, $C=.3$ is obtained by setting the unconditioned probability $P(Y\leq .5)$ equal to .64 (where $Y = $ insurance payment = $X-C$) and then solving for $C$ using $$\int_{0}^{.5+C} 2x~dx = .64$$

My question is, what happened to the condition? Is "given a loss $X$" already baked into the expression $P(X-C\leq .5)$, and therefore just a bit of misdirection? My own attempt involved defining $$Y= \begin{cases} 0~~\text{if } X\leq C\\\ X-C~~ \text{if }X>C\end{cases}$$

and then solving for $C$ using$$P(Y\leq .5\vert X>C) = \frac{P(X-C \leq .5 \cap X>C)}{P(X>C)} = \frac{P(C \leq X \leq C+.5)}{1-P(X\leq C)} = \frac{\int_{C}^{C+.5} 2x~dx}{1 - \int_{0}^{C} 2x~dx} = .64$$ That gives $C \approx .32316$

But that didn't seem right because it skips over the losses that are less than $C$. Any help with answering these questions would be greatly appreciated!

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

1
$\begingroup$

The "given" in the statement of the problem shouldn't be interpreted as indicating a conditional probability. The payout from the policy is $$ (X-C)^+=\cases{ X-C,&if $X>C$,\cr 0& if $X\le C$.\cr} $$ You are asked to find $C$ such that $$ P((X-C)^+\le .5) =.64. $$ Because $\{(X-C)^+\le .5\}=\{X\le C+.5\}$, the above probabulity can be less that $1$ only if $C$ is less than $.5$. In this case $$ P((X-C)^+\le .5) =P(X\le C+.5) =(C+.5)^2. $$

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.