Questions tagged [comment-flags]
Questions regarding the flagging of comments. For flags in general, use [flags].
242 questions
33 votes
6 answers
1k views
Is "this didn't work" an okay comment?
Generally speaking, we flag comments like "this worked!" or "thanks!" as "no longer needed". My reasoning for this is usually that "thanks" is redundant with an ...
22 votes
0 answers
154 views
Rate-limited flagging attempt shows generic error message instead of the actual error
Since the comments overhaul, submitting a second comment flag within 5 seconds of a previous comment flag (haven't tested on post flags) now shows a generic, unhelpful error message: Before the ...
2 votes
1 answer
91 views
Retracting flag on a comment that is answered by a useful secondary answer
I flagged this comment as being not needed. Later I saw another answer that was focused on the probable cause of the commented issue. I tried to retract the flag, but the software currently seems to ...
-8 votes
1 answer
301 views
Why was this comment flag I raised declined? [duplicate]
I flagged a comment here as No longer needed. The flag was marked Declined, but the comment still got deleted. Stack Exchange Inc hates its users and wants them all to leave. I think it falls under ...
-16 votes
1 answer
271 views
Is commenting literally "What new does your answer bring which have not been already said in the other answers?" proper or not?
That is literally a comment I stumbled upon (not on my contribs :), nevertheless I've seen many similar comments throughout the years, especially to new users. While I generally agree with the some of ...
6 votes
4 answers
895 views
"Nobody in their right mind would do that" -- unfriendly or unkind or neither?
In this question the asker presents their C++ code which uses a custom linked list data structure (as provided by LeetCode), aiming to sort it. One commenter writes (I highlight in bold): Don't just ...
33 votes
1 answer
1k views
Why were "no longer needed" flags declined?
Comments to this answer are confusing because the answerer actually already addressed the issues with edits. They are, thus, no longer needed and should be removed. I flagged accordingly but it was ...
2 votes
2 answers
352 views
How should I handle comments posted as answers to off-topic questions?
Numerous times I've run across an off-topic question that someone has posted comments on that attempt to answer the question. I understand the desire to help people but such comments should not be ...
127 votes
3 answers
3k views
Why is this comment not unfriendly/unkind?
Two days ago I reported this comment as unfriendly/unkind: Whoever downvoted my question, you really are a weird person. Downvoting with a comment as WHY downvoted makes sense so that I can at least ...
16 votes
1 answer
482 views
Do flags affect a user's ability to comment?
I recently had a problem with a user commenting excessively on a post of mine. At first it seemed like they were trying to help, but many of their statements were verifiably false and the longer we ...
16 votes
1 answer
173 views
Invalid Code of Conduct anchor links in the comment flagging dialog
When I click the flag icon to flag a comment, a dialog box opens with four options. The first two contain links to the Code of Conduct: It contains harassment, bigotry, or abuse. This comment attacks ...
8 votes
0 answers
78 views
Flag history page shows no title/link for flags on collection comments
For flags on post comments, there's a div.answer-summary > div.answer-link > a. For flags on collection comments, there's no such anchor. There's no indicator of what was flagged or what the ...
28 votes
1 answer
411 views
How can we best flag comments suggesting that askers upload their code to GitHub (or another cloud service)?
More and more I'm seeing vague "something is broken but I don't know what please help" questions that should be closed, but instead other users post in the comments "upload your code to ...
0 votes
1 answer
247 views
Should users encountering benign but irrelevant comments flag them as not needed?
I just flagged the following two comments from the question Is it worth bothering to align AVX-256 memory stores?; Good question! I don't know the answer off the top of my head and don't have the ...
-15 votes
5 answers
340 views
Introduce a new post-owner-only flag that combines "no longer needed" with a notification of the commenter of an update to the post
For the backstory, see this post about prematurely deleted, user-targeted "please see my update" comments. Motivation: Prevent comment proliferation by making a dedicated flag available to ...