Skip to main content
added 1 character in body; edited title
Source Link
Oblivious Sage
  • 56.3k
  • 22
  • 180
  • 245

Size How do size increases andaffect creatures with specifically long appendages?

Do iI understand the rules correctly if iI say that a creature with long appendages, like a dragon's neck, doesn't grow proportionally when it'sits size increases?

I'll use the Serpopardserpopard as an example since it'sits flavour texts says it'sits neck is two times the length of hisits body, making the example very obvious, but it works the same for any other creature with less absurd proportions.

A medium serpopard occupies 5 feet and his neck allows him to hit creatures 15 feet away. If he becomes large the proportion become 10/15 (not 20 because he is a quadruped), if he is huge then it's 15/20, the bigger he gets the shorter the neck becomes in proportion to his body.

Did iI interpret the rules correctly? I always thought size increases were additions to the base numbers but this is so stupid that it made me question if iI didn't apply them wrong the whole time while instead they work more similarly to the reach weapon property, that it's not just an increase to the reach but instead a multiplier to your normal reach based on size.

This cannot possibly be RAI, iI cannot even imagine them answering a FAQ about the topiç with "Yes, the serpopard neck inis intended to become shorter the bigger he gets".

Edit: i thought about it a little more and the situation is even worse. The

The serpopard has a 15 feet reach with hit'shis bite due to his neck but if you give him a gore attack his reach will still be 5 feet with his horns, even tho they should also have a 15 feet reach.

Did iI miss a fundamental rule? Cause this situation is more common than iI thought.

Do iWill I break the game balance if iI fix it in my games?

Size increases and creatures with long appendages

Do i understand the rules correctly if i say that a creature with long appendages, like a dragon's neck, doesn't grow proportionally when it's size increases?

I'll use the Serpopard as an example since it's flavour texts says it's neck is two times the length of his body, making the example very obvious but it works the same for any other creature with less absurd proportions.

A medium serpopard occupies 5 feet and his neck allows him to hit creatures 15 feet away. If he becomes large the proportion become 10/15 (not 20 because he is a quadruped), if he is huge then it's 15/20, the bigger he gets the shorter the neck becomes in proportion to his body.

Did i interpret the rules correctly? I always thought size increases were additions to the base numbers but this is so stupid that it made me question if i didn't apply them wrong the whole time while instead they work more similarly to the reach weapon property that it's not just an increase to the reach but instead a multiplier to your normal reach based on size.

This cannot possibly be RAI, i cannot even imagine them answering a FAQ about the topiç with "Yes, the serpopard neck in intended to become shorter the bigger he gets".

Edit: i thought about it a little more and the situation is even worse. The serpopard has a 15 feet reach with hit's bite due to his neck but if you give him a gore attack his reach will still be 5 feet with his horns, even tho they should also have a 15 feet reach.

Did i miss a fundamental rule? Cause this situation is more common than i thought.

Do i break the game balance if i fix it in my games?

How do size increases affect creatures with specifically long appendages?

Do I understand the rules correctly if I say that a creature with long appendages, like a dragon's neck, doesn't grow proportionally when its size increases?

I'll use the serpopard as an example since its flavour texts says its neck is two times the length of its body, making the example very obvious, but it works the same for any other creature with less absurd proportions.

A medium serpopard occupies 5 feet and his neck allows him to hit creatures 15 feet away. If he becomes large the proportion become 10/15 (not 20 because he is a quadruped), if he is huge then it's 15/20, the bigger he gets the shorter the neck becomes in proportion to his body.

Did I interpret the rules correctly? I always thought size increases were additions to the base numbers but this is so stupid that it made me question if I didn't apply them wrong the whole time while instead they work more similarly to the reach weapon property, that it's not just an increase to the reach but instead a multiplier to your normal reach based on size.

This cannot possibly be RAI, I cannot even imagine them answering a FAQ about the topiç with "Yes, the serpopard neck is intended to become shorter the bigger he gets".

Edit: i thought about it a little more and the situation is even worse.

The serpopard has a 15 feet reach with his bite due to his neck but if you give him a gore attack his reach will still be 5 feet with his horns, even tho they should also have a 15 feet reach.

Did I miss a fundamental rule? Cause this situation is more common than I thought.

Will I break the game balance if I fix it in my games?

added 412 characters in body
Source Link
GodDog
  • 610
  • 10

Do i understand the rules correctly if i say that a creature with long appendages, like a dragon's neck, doesn't grow proportionally when it's size increases?

I'll use the Serpopard as an example since it's flavour texts says it's neck is two times the length of his body, making the example very obvious but it works the same for any other creature with less absurd proportions.

A medium serpopard occupies 5 feet and his neck allows him to hit creatures 15 feet away. If he becomes large the proportion become 10/15 (not 20 because he is a quadruped), if he is huge then it's 15/20, the bigger he gets the shorter the neck becomes in proportion to his body.

Did i interpret the rules correctly? I always thought size increases were additions to the base numbers but this is so stupid that it made me question if i didn't apply them wrong the whole time while instead they work more similarly to the reach weapon property that it's not just an increase to the reach but instead a multiplier to your normal reach based on size.

This cannot possibly be RAI, i cannot even imagine them answering a FAQ about the topiç with "Yes, the serpopard neck in intended to become shorter the bigger he gets".

Edit: i thought about it a little more and the situation is even worse. The serpopard has a 15 feet reach with hit's bite due to his neck but if you give him a gore attack his reach will still be 5 feet with his horns, even tho they should also have a 15 feet reach.

Did i miss a fundamental rule? Cause this situation is more common than i thought.

Do i break the game balance if i fix it in my games?

Do i understand the rules correctly if i say that a creature with long appendages, like a dragon's neck, doesn't grow proportionally when it's size increases?

I'll use the Serpopard as an example since it's flavour texts says it's neck is two times the length of his body, making the example very obvious but it works the same for any other creature with less absurd proportions.

A medium serpopard occupies 5 feet and his neck allows him to hit creatures 15 feet away. If he becomes large the proportion become 10/15 (not 20 because he is a quadruped), if he is huge then it's 15/20, the bigger he gets the shorter the neck becomes in proportion to his body.

Did i interpret the rules correctly? I always thought size increases were additions to the base numbers but this is so stupid that it made me question if i didn't apply them wrong the whole time while instead they work more similarly to the reach weapon property that it's not just an increase to the reach but instead a multiplier to your normal reach based on size.

This cannot possibly be RAI, i cannot even imagine them answering a FAQ about the topiç with "Yes, the serpopard neck in intended to become shorter the bigger he gets".

Do i understand the rules correctly if i say that a creature with long appendages, like a dragon's neck, doesn't grow proportionally when it's size increases?

I'll use the Serpopard as an example since it's flavour texts says it's neck is two times the length of his body, making the example very obvious but it works the same for any other creature with less absurd proportions.

A medium serpopard occupies 5 feet and his neck allows him to hit creatures 15 feet away. If he becomes large the proportion become 10/15 (not 20 because he is a quadruped), if he is huge then it's 15/20, the bigger he gets the shorter the neck becomes in proportion to his body.

Did i interpret the rules correctly? I always thought size increases were additions to the base numbers but this is so stupid that it made me question if i didn't apply them wrong the whole time while instead they work more similarly to the reach weapon property that it's not just an increase to the reach but instead a multiplier to your normal reach based on size.

This cannot possibly be RAI, i cannot even imagine them answering a FAQ about the topiç with "Yes, the serpopard neck in intended to become shorter the bigger he gets".

Edit: i thought about it a little more and the situation is even worse. The serpopard has a 15 feet reach with hit's bite due to his neck but if you give him a gore attack his reach will still be 5 feet with his horns, even tho they should also have a 15 feet reach.

Did i miss a fundamental rule? Cause this situation is more common than i thought.

Do i break the game balance if i fix it in my games?

Source Link
GodDog
  • 610
  • 10

Size increases and creatures with long appendages

Do i understand the rules correctly if i say that a creature with long appendages, like a dragon's neck, doesn't grow proportionally when it's size increases?

I'll use the Serpopard as an example since it's flavour texts says it's neck is two times the length of his body, making the example very obvious but it works the same for any other creature with less absurd proportions.

A medium serpopard occupies 5 feet and his neck allows him to hit creatures 15 feet away. If he becomes large the proportion become 10/15 (not 20 because he is a quadruped), if he is huge then it's 15/20, the bigger he gets the shorter the neck becomes in proportion to his body.

Did i interpret the rules correctly? I always thought size increases were additions to the base numbers but this is so stupid that it made me question if i didn't apply them wrong the whole time while instead they work more similarly to the reach weapon property that it's not just an increase to the reach but instead a multiplier to your normal reach based on size.

This cannot possibly be RAI, i cannot even imagine them answering a FAQ about the topiç with "Yes, the serpopard neck in intended to become shorter the bigger he gets".