8

I'm trying to create simple MVC skeleton and I'm stuck with dependencies.

This is what I have now:

$config = new Config(); $database = new Database($config); $uri = new Uri('article/5'); $request = new Request($uri); $response = new Response; $router = new Router; $dispatcher = new Dispatcher($request, $response, $router); $dispatcher->dispatch(); // Routing, instantiate controller, execute action, send response

The question is: how can any object get access to any dependency?

Some examples:

  • Controller may need Config to get output formatting options.
  • Mapper may need Database to perform queries.
  • Any Controller / Helper needs access to Log.
  • Helper may need any number of dependencies (ex.:Uri_Helper needs Router).

The only possibility I can think of is to use Registry, but this violates Law of Demeter (ask what you really need).

Improve this question

2 Answers 2

Reset to default
5

You write factories(excellen article). This could be totally boring(like the article mentions) so you could use a DI-framework like for example:

  • Symfony DIC: See Juraj's post.
  • PD
  • Yadif
  • Drip(PHP4): but hasn't been updated in a while.

Also I would like to point out that Misko's blog is very interesting and has a lot of good reads on how to do testing properly. Especially the guide to writing testable code is a must read.

P.S: I think you should be writing factories, because PHP is a scripting language and you should use as little code as possible to make your site fast. That's the problem with some PHP frameworks.

Rasmus Ledorf(PHP inventor) 's quote:

Many frameworks may look very appealing at first glance because they seem to reduce web application development to a couple of trivial steps leading to some code generation and often automatic schema detection, but these same shortcuts are likely to be your bottlenecks as well since they achieve this simplicity by sacrifizing flexibility and performance. Nothing is going to build your application for you, no matter what it promises. You are going to have to build it yourself. Instead of starting by fixing the mistakes in some foreign framework and refactoring all the things that don't apply to your environment spend your time building a lean and reusable pattern that fits your requirements directly. In the end I think you will find that your homegrown small framework has saved you time and aggravation and you end up with a better product.

Improve this answer
Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

Comments

1

You may use a dependency injection container like Symfony DIC. You define your objects, configuration and wiring inside the container, which than takes care of instantiation.

Improve this answer

Comments

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.