82

Possible Duplicates:
What is Closures/Lambda in PHP or Javascript in layman terms?
What is the difference between a 'closure' and a 'lambda'?

Hi,

I have been unable to find a definition that clearly explains the differences between a closure and an anonymous function.

Most references I have seen clearly specify that they are distinct "things" yet I can't seem to get my head around why.

Could someone please simplify it for me? What are the specific differences between these two language features? Which one is more appropriate in what scenarios?

1

1 Answer 1

114

An anonymous function is just a function that has no name; nothing more. A closure is a function that captures the state of the surrounding environment.

An anonymous function does not necessarily need to create a closure, and a closure is not created only for anonymous functions.

Consider this hypothetical counter-example. Consider a language Foo which does not support closures but supports anonymous functions. This language may either not compile or throw an error for the code below because "greeting" is not defined in the scope of the inner function. The fact that it is anonymous is irrelevant.

function outer() { var greeting = "hello "; (function(name) { alert(greeting + name); })("John Doe"); } 

Let's consider an actual language now that does support closures - JavaScript. Taking the same example as above, but naming the inner function this time gives:

function outer() { var greeting = "hello "; (function inner(name) { alert(greeting + name); })("John Doe"); } 

Although the inner function is not anonymous anymore, it still captures state from the surrounding environment.

Closures provide much needed convenience, as otherwise we would be passing every single dependency of the function as an argument.

function outer() { var greeting = "hello "; (function(name, greeting) { alert(greeting + name); })("John Doe", greeting); } 
Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

9 Comments

Can you cite some sources for the definitions used in your answer?
@Pacerier I haven't used any definitions other than what is already referenced in the question, and that's basically closures, and anonymous functions. I came up with the examples on my own, so can't provide external references for those.
To clarify, leaving out the parameter greeting from the anonymous function in your last example would still result in valid code, because of JavaScripts (highly unintuitive) scoping model.
@NielsAbildgaard - good point, I was just illustrating what it would look like in a language that does not have closures. It's JavaScript syntax and that makes it confusing but the idea was a generic language without closures.
It seems that PHP's official docs use "closure" and "anonymous function" interchangeably, even though their closures don't capture surrounding state without using the 'use' language construct. "Anonymous functions, also known as closures, allow the creation of functions which have no specified name." php.net/manual/en/functions.anonymous.php
|

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.