9
$\begingroup$

What I mean is that we have $T \in \mathcal{S}'(\mathbb{R}^n)$ such that for all $f \in C^\infty_c (\mathbb{R}^n)$, we have that $\mathrm{supp}(T \ast f)$ is compact, and we're asking whether $\mathrm{supp}(T)$ is compact.

I believe I have an argument proving this (due primarily to Hannah Cairo), but it's been hell trying to find it in the literature. Near-converses of it are common (e.g. page 290 in Trèves' TVS book) and easy at any rate. Is this well-known / does it have a very simple argument?

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ I don't have the mathematical skills to make a rigorous argument, but the simple argument is that convolution spreads the support except in carefully constructed counter examples. If for ALL $f$, the convolution is compactly supported, this includes functions that are not part of this carefully constructed set. So T must be compact support $\endgroup$ Commented Nov 16 at 18:53
  • $\begingroup$ Intuitively, I would take $f_\varepsilon \to \delta_x$, the Dirac delta at point $x$ ... if $\mathrm{supp} f_\varepsilon \subseteq B_\varepsilon$, the ball of size $\varepsilon$, then $\mathrm{supp}(T*f_{\varepsilon}) \subseteq \mathrm{supp}(T) + B_\varepsilon$ $\endgroup$ Commented Nov 17 at 19:03

1 Answer 1

3
$\begingroup$

I wouldn't say it counts as well known, but if you have a look at L. Schwartz' Théorie des distributions, chap. VI, § 7 and § 8, you can observe an interesting trick involving fundamental solutions of differential operators that is used several times to deduce properties of distributions from the properties of their regularisations.

A general result

Theorem. — Let $K$ be a compact neighbourhood of $0$ in $\mathbb R^n$ and let $F$ be a subspace of $\mathcal D'(\mathbb R^n)$ such that for every $T\in F$ and every $f\in\mathcal D(\mathbb R^n)$ supported in $K$, the smooth function $T*f$ belongs to $F$. Suppose that there is a norm $\|\cdot\|$ on $F$ for which it is a Banach space with a topology finer than the one induced by $\mathcal D'(\mathbb R^n)$. Let $T\in\mathcal D'(\mathbb R^n)$. The following conditions are equivalent:

  1. $T$ is a linear combination of derivatives of elements of $F$.
  2. For every $f\in\mathcal D(\mathbb R^n)$ supported in $K$, the smooth function $T*f$ belongs to $F$.

The proof below is a mix of the proofs of chap. VI, § 7, Theorem XXII and § 8, Theorem XXV in L. Schwartz' book, where the trick is to bring into the picture convolutions with functions of class $\mathrm C^m$ for some $m\in\mathbb N$ rather than smooth functions and use a fundamental solution of class $\mathrm C^m$ of some differential operator to convolve with $T$.

Proof of the theorem. — (1$\Rightarrow$2) Suppose that there are finite families $(T_i)_{i\in I}$ and $(\alpha_i)_{i\in I}$ of elements of $F$ and $\mathbb N^n$ respectively such that $T=\sum_{i\in I}\partial^{\alpha_i}T_i$. If $f\in\mathcal D(\mathbb R^n)$ is supported in $K$, then $$T*f=\sum_{i\in I}\partial^{\alpha_i}T_i*f=\sum_{i\in I}T_i*\partial^{\alpha_i}f$$ which shows that $T*f\in F$ since each $\partial^{\alpha_i}f$ is smooth and supported in $K$.

(2$\Rightarrow$1) Suppose that $T*f\in F$ for every $f\in\mathcal D(\mathbb R^n)$ supported in $K$.

Step 1. There exists an open neighbourhood of $0$ in $K$ as well as a $m\in\mathbb N$ such that for every function $f$ on $\mathbb R^n$ of class $\mathrm C^m$ supported in $U$, the distribution $T*f$ belongs to $F$.

Denote by $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ be the space of all smooth functions on $\mathbb R^n$ supported in $K$ endowed with the topology of "uniform convergence of all derivatives", making it a Fréchet space. The closed graph theorem tells you that the linear map $f\mapsto T*f$ from $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ to $F$ is continuous. There is therefore a $m\in\mathbb N$ as well as a $r>0$ such that for every $f\in\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$, $$ \sup_{|\alpha|\leq m}\sup_{x\in\mathbb R^n}|\partial^\alpha f(x)|\leq r\implies\|T*f\|\leq 1. $$ Let $U$ be an open neighbourhood of $0$ in $\mathbb R^n$ contained in $K$ and denote by $\mathcal D_U^m(\mathbb R^n)$ the space of function on $\mathbb R^n$ of class $\mathrm C^m$ and supported in $U$ endowed with the norm $$ f\mapsto\sup_{|\alpha|\leq m}\sup_{x\in\mathbb R^n}|\partial^\alpha f(x)|. $$ It is clear that $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)\cap\mathcal D_U^m(\mathbb R^n)$ is dense in $\mathcal D_U^m(\mathbb R^n$, hence the existence of a continuous linear map $u$ from $\mathcal D_U^m(\mathbb R^n)$ to $F$ such that $u(f)=T*f$ for every $f\in\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)\cap\mathcal D_U^m(\mathbb R^n)$. The linear maps $f\mapsto u(f)$ and $f\mapsto T*f$ from $\mathcal D_U^m(\mathbb R^n)$ to $\mathcal D'(\mathbb R^n)$ are then continuous, coincide on a dense set and therefore must be equal.

Step 2. There are functions $f$ and $g$ on $\mathbb R^n$ of class $\mathrm C^m$ supported in $U$ as well as a translation invariant differential $\Psi$ such that $f+\Psi(g)=\delta_0$.

Let $E$ be the function $(t_1,t_2,\dots,t_n)\mapsto (m+1)!^{-n}(t_1t_2\cdots t_n)^{m+1}H(t_1)H(t_2)\cdots H(t_n)$ (where $H$ is the Heaviside function) and let $\Psi$ be the differential operator $(\partial_1\partial_2\cdots\partial_n)^{m+2}$. It easy to check that $\Psi(E)=\delta_0$ and that $E$ is of class $\mathrm C^m$ on $\mathbb R^n$ and of class $\mathrm C^\infty$ on $\mathbb R^n\setminus\{0\}$. Let $\varphi\in\mathcal D_U^m(\mathbb R^n)$ be such that $\varphi=1$ on a neighbourhood of $0$ in $U$. The function $g=\varphi E$ obviously belongs to $\mathcal D_U^m(\mathbb R^n)$. The function $f=\Psi((1-\varphi)E)$ is then obviously smooth and the relation $$ \Psi((1-\varphi)E)+\Psi(\varphi E)=\Psi(E)=\delta_0 $$ show that $f$ is supported in $U$ (since $\Psi(\varphi E)$ and $\delta_0$ are) and that $f+\Psi(g)=\delta_0$.

Step 3. Conclusion.

Notice that $ T=T*\delta_0=T*f+T*\Psi(g)=T*f+\Psi(T*g)$. Since $f,g\in\mathcal D_U^m(\mathbb R^n)$, you have $T*f\in F$ and $T*g\in F$ and this shows that $T$ is indeed a linear combination of derivatives of elements of $F$.

Relation to your question

Thanks to the general result above, you can see your question boils down to finding a good Banach space of compactly supported distributions.

Lemma. — Let $K$ be a compact neighbourhood of $0$ in $\mathbb R^n$ and let $T\in\mathcal D'(\mathbb R^n)$ be such that for every $f\in\mathcal D(\mathbb R^n)$ supported in $K$, the smooth function $T*f$ is compactly supported. There exists a compact subset $L$ of $\mathbb R^n$ such that for every $f\in\mathcal D(\mathbb R^n)$ supported in $K$, the smooth function $T*f$ is supported in $L$.

Hence, you can for example take $F$ to be the Banach space of all continuous functions supported in $L$ with the norm of uniform convergence, and the previous theorem tells you that $T$ is a linear combination of derivatives of compactly supported continuous functions and is therefore compactly supported.

Proof of the lemma. — Once again, denote by $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ be the space of all smooth functions on $\mathbb R^n$ supported in $K$ endowed with the topology of "uniform convergence of all derivatives", for which it is a Fréchet space. For every $k\in\mathbb N$, let $F_k$ be the closed subspace of $\mathcal D(\mathbb R^n)$ consisting of the smooth functions on $\mathbb R^n$ supported in $[-k,k]$ and let $E_k$ be the subspace of $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ preimage of $F_k$ by $f\mapsto T*f$. There are some general forms of the closed graph theorem that tell you that the map $f\mapsto T*f$ from $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ to $\mathcal D(\mathbb R^n)$ is continuous. Hence, each $E_k$ is closed in $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$. Moreover, since the subspaces $F_k$ cover $\mathcal D(\mathbb R^n)$, the subspaces $E_k$ cover $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ and since $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ is a Baire space, at least one of the $E_k$ has non-empty interior in $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ and therefore is equal to $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$.

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ In the proof of the lemma, I'm not sure I follow the very last step, from some $E_k$ having nonempty interior to being equal to $\mathcal{D}_K (\mathbb{R}^n)$. $\endgroup$ Commented Nov 17 at 14:04
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @sandivald $E_k$ having non-empty interior tells you it is a neighbourhood of $0$ in $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$. So if $f\in\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ and $R$ is a very large positive real number, you have $\frac 1Rf\in E_k$ because $E_k$ is a neighbourhood of $0$ in $\mathcal D_K(\mathbb R^n)$ and then $f=R\frac 1Rf\in E_k$ because $E_k$ is a vector space. $\endgroup$ Commented Nov 17 at 17:27

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.